Edible Landscaping: replacing annual Batchelor's Buttons

 My edible landscape is going through another transition. A significant number of annual edible flowers need to be pulled but their removal will leave holes (OK, craters) in my design. I've been putting off doing this clean up task because I couldn't decide what I wanted to do with the empty space. I think I now have a plan.

August 2014

August 2014

This is this garden's second year. Last year, I didn't get to plant anything until May and consequently the annuals sown from seed were still in bloom in August. In the photos above, taken almost exactly a year ago, you can see how the Batchelor's Buttons in particular are still blossoming.

Fast forward a year and I have brown plants which have gone to seed. Batchelor's Buttons are amazing self seeders and I had seedlings well on the way to maturity in April. This of course meant they peaked much earlier.

                                                                                June 2015                                                        Photo: Michael St. Jean

                                                                                        June 2015                                                 Photo: Michael St. Jean

                                                                                 June 2015                                                         Photo: Michael St. Jean

These photos were taken during the URI Master Gardener Tour in June, The Buttons are gorgeous. I knew then I was in trouble and started to think about what I was going to do when they expired. These plants reseeded so well I had at least double the number of plants I did last year and once the flowers started to fade the task of deadheading them was overwhelming. I'd stand in one spot for an hour and not make a dent.

Garden right of the path.

Garden left of the path.

Consequently, the plants went to seed much earlier than they needed to. I've left the plants for the birds to pick at the seeds and they have been a big hit. Slowly, I've removed the plants as they died to the point where they look straggly. The garden on the right hand side is further along than the left, as you can see. This is because of the path of the sun. I could get away with leaving the Batchelor's Buttons on the left for a bit longer but if I just remove them from the right hand garden it will look unbalanced.

You can see how bare this section will be with out the Batchelor's Buttons. The beans I planted next to the walkway didn't germinate.

My plan is to replace the sections in the front along the path with Ballhead cabbages and the transplants are ready to go out. These will fill the space until it is time to put the garden to bed in the fall.

Seen from the porch, the right hand garden doesn't look that bad.

Looking down from the porch, you can see all the dead Batchelor's Buttons in the left hand garden.

Next year, I plan on replacing the Buttons along the path with an edible perennial. I have some ideas but I wonder what you think - any suggestions? Also, what would you do? Remove all the Buttons now, remove just the ones on the right, or wait until the plants on the left look as bad as the ones on the right?

Let me know!

Sue